Diversity is nothing without inclusion

Deputy Police Inspector Daniel Benner believes that diversity is a management treasure, and inclusion is the key to the treasure chest. "We can strive for gender balance in hiring, for example, but if we don't bring diversity into play when making decisions, we miss out on the opportunities that diversity offers," he says.

According to Deputy Police Inspector Daniel Benner, the 'Where's Wally' books can illustrate one of the challenges of leading an organisation towards more diversity: the books immediately represent a very broad diversity with many people and a great wealth of detail. But the concept of the books is also to look for something specific. Namely the white man Wally. That tunnel vision can show public leaders how opportunities can be missed. Because despite quite extensive diversity, it is not taken into account.

"Research indicates that diversity increases the quality of decision-making processes, and Where's Wally can teach us that diversity cannot stand alone. We can strive for gender diversity in employment, but if it is not included in the decisions, then we pass over the opportunities that lie in diversity. Diversity is nothing without inclusion. If we simply look for what we usually do and do what we usually do, then diversity changes nothing," says Daniel Benner. And he emphasises that his purpose is not to criticise Where's Wally books, but simply to draw a thoughtful and recognisable parallel.

1) Policy – Diversity promotes the organisation's social responsibility and sustainability.

2) Economy – Diversity promotes profit creation or profit realisation.

3) Strategy – Diversity promotes utilisation of the organisation's talent pool.

Professor & MPG lecturer Sara Louise Muhr and Ph.D. & psychologist Christina Lundsgaard Ottsen point to the core arguments for including diversity.

"As a leader, you must practice accepting your own imperfection. A leader must not necessarily know the best or the most, but embrace diversity and use it to make better decisions."

Deputy Police Inspector Daniel Benner

Meritocracy can paradoxically slow down diversity

Daniel has conducted a number of interviews with police employees who explain that they believe in meritocracy - that the most suitable person gets the job. The research also suggests that in Western societies, there is generally a high belief in meritocracy.

Typically, a potential leader works in a management position for a year and a half. Then the position is advertised and, in principle, anyone can apply for it. This is also the case elsewhere in the public sector, and the argument can be that leadership must be learned in practice and not just in theory.

"I don't dispute that fact. However, the implications of the master's project suggest that we can structurally remove some diversity barriers by advertising the position and making it open to everyone prior to the term of office. My respondents believe that meritocracy works in the police. But at the same time, they also mention that they may have a perception that positions may in some cases be filled in advance. This leads me to say that meritocracy is more at stake than in play, because it doesn't work the way we think it does, and this is due to our own bias. If we don't more actively seek to block some of the barriers to diversity, we risk missing out on a talent pool, which means there's a risk that it's not always the most suitable person who gets promoted," he says and continues: "The people I've interviewed want gender diversity and diversity in general, but at the same time they find it difficult to explain why there isn't any. My guess is that bias can explain the lack of gender diversity."

According to Daniel, there may be an equality bias at play, where we recruit those who are similar to ourselves. This means that management reproduces itself, and if a person has worked in a position that is advertised, we will compare all other candidates to that person. And this is typically in favor of the person who has served in the position. Therefore, it makes sense to structure the process so that the selection for the managerial position is based on applications at the beginning of the process rather than at the end, he says.

Another solution would be to anonymise applicants as far as possible in the process. Both in terms of name and photo.

Daniel emphasises that it is of course also relevant to look at the fact that there is a special dynamic at play in the police, because there is a deep dependence on the admission to the police academy. If more women are not admitted there, it will be difficult to increase the proportion of female leaders with a police education.

Don't solve the challenge before you know the problem

Daniel's MPG education has helped him delve deeper into problems. Both in relation to the gender diversity assignment to identify the underlying bias that may be contributing to the gender imbalance, and other problems he encounters in his work.

"I investigate the problem instead of immediately pursuing a solution. And we can call it a problem, because problems are there to be understood and looked at from different angles and then the solution can be qualified. Over the last decade, we've been clucking our tongues and renaming problems "challenges", which is a very action-oriented term that doesn't require much thought and understanding. Because if we solve the challenges before we know the problems, we don't understand what's really wrong, and there's a danger that it becomes a solution to a symptom rather than to a problem," he says.

When asked if he has any advice for other public sector leaders to promote diversity in their organisation, he replies: "As a leader, you have to practice being comfortable with your own imperfection. A leader should not necessarily know best or most, but embrace diversity and use it to make better decisions. The worst decisions I make are the ones where I don't involve others and stay in my own echo chamber. Start by asking someone for advice, even sometimes those you wouldn't normally ask. Because it's important to remember that it's not just about diversity, but also about how we include it."

Here you can read Daniel Benner's master's project on how the paradox of meritocracy and bias affects gender diversity in the police. The document is in Danish 🇩🇰.

Read Daniel Benner's Master's project

The Copenhagen MBA participants talking in the lobby

Full-Time MBA

Elevate your career with a triple-accredited one-year Full-time MBA programme built around sustainability, authenticity and innovation.

Learn more

Sara Louise Muhr teaches in front of a whiteboard

Diversity and inclusion mangement

Improve your ability to ensure diverse representation in management and subject-specific groups, and gain tools to manage diversity in a way that fosters an inclusive work culture with room to develop each individual’s unique skills.

Learn more

International Business Strategy

Do you want to learn how to lead and develop your business in a global and diverse market? Do you want to develop skills and knowledge to design and execute effective international strategies? This course will expand your knowledge in leading a multinational company.

Lær mere

Diversity is nothing without inclusion

This is what research on diversity says

"As a leader, you must practice accepting your own imperfection. A leader must not necessarily know the best or the most, but embrace diversity and use it to make better decisions."

Read the project: Strategic diversity in Danish police

Keep learning