Professor Edward Ashbee, Department of International Economics, Government and Business
Is there likely to be a trade war between the US and the EU?Even if Trump backs away from his commitment to all-round protectionism, there will be very serious trade skirmishes. We can, at the least, expect targeted tariffs. And it won’t just be the German car industry that is likely to be at the forefront. For example, if the new administration presses ahead in its bid to secure Greenland, Danish firms could be in the firing line. The European chemical, machinery and equipment industries could also be vulnerable. The EU won't of course sit idly by. Having had time to prepare, it will probably respond with a mix of carrots (increasing European purchases of US products or offering cooperation around China) and sticks (imposing tariffs on key US goods). In short, expect battles, but probably not an all-out fight to the finish.
Despite the dangers of transatlantic trade battles, what are the chances of a US-Europe trade deal?A decade ago, the EU and the US sought to create the gargantuan Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP) but, even after five years of negotiation, there was still no prospect of agreement. For its part, despite all its talk of protectionism, the first Trump administration held out the promise to the EU of a deal with “no tariffs, no barriers, no subsidies, all together as one package”. Despite the alluring simplicity of this, many Europeans believed that offered, in practice, a “race to the bottom” that would for example threaten the continent’s agricultural sector, health provision and labour standards. Trump 2.0 may well make a repeat offer. After all, although he frequently seems to celebrate tariffs as an end in themselves, he and his team also regard them as a form of leverage so as to secure particular economic or political goals. A simple trade deal is tempting for many of Trump’s backers because it would prise open European markets for US firms. This is however something that the EU could not concede insofar as such a deal would pose an existential threat to the European model.
How can Europe best respond to US-China rivalries?We should again note Trump’s exceptional unpredictability. He has been unrelenting in lambasting the threats that he claims China poses to the US economy but there have also been inconsistencies. TikTok won a reprieve. Whereas some of Trump’s supporters forcefully back Taiwan, he has been more equivocal. He, after all, almost always believes that there is a deal to be made. The EU is also torn. It has its own concerns about what it sees as trade-distorting Chinese subsidies, but some European countries are now talking in more balanced terms about engagement than a few years ago. If, however, China’s relations with the US deteriorate further under Trump, Beijing will probably go far in making efforts to peel Europe away from the US. If this happens would Europe have the economic might and the political resolve to defy Washington? Maybe but the problem for the continent is that there might well be 27 different answers.